Judge in trial of Satellite Beach man accused in loud-music killing steps aside

Published On: Jul 02 2013 09:54:55 AM EDT

Florida Today

Michael Dunn is accused of shooting 17-year-old Jordan Davis last November 23 after getting into an argument with Davis and three other teens.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. -

The judge originally slated to oversee the murder trial of a Satellite Beach man accused of killing a Jacksonville teen over loud music has taken herself off the case.

According to the Duval County Clerk of Court webpage, the recusal order for Judge Mallory Cooper was entered Monday.

Cooper is the second judge to step aside from the high-profile Michael Dunn case, Local 6 News partner Florida Today reported.

According to Jackelyn Barnard, the public information officer for the State Attorney's Office, no one in the State Attorney's Office asked Cooper to recuse herself.

The site also shows that Judge Russell Healey has been reassigned to take over the case.

There are a number of reasons why judges would recuse themselves, and why an attorney would ask them to be removed, including a conflict of interest and scheduling conflicts.

Dunn is accused of shooting 17-year-old Jordan Davis last November 23 after getting into an argument with Davis and three other teens.

Police say Dunn argued with the boys about the loud music coming from the red SUV they were riding in, and after they refused to turn the music down Dunn went to his car, retrieved his gun and opened fire on the unarmed teens.

Judge Suzanne Bass removed herself on May 23 after Dunn's lawyers raised doubts of a fair trial when she denied Dunn's plea to be declared indigent and be eligible for taxpayer funds for his defense.

So with a third judge assigned to the Dunn trial, Florida Today asked former prosecutor Richard Kuritz if the high judge turnover on the case is caused by underlying issues.

"It's not that unusual, most of the time one judge recuses because they said something they shouldn't have said or someone interpreted something incorrectly but for a high profile case to go through one or two judges doesn't surprise me," said Richard Kuritz.

John Phillips, the Davis Family attorney in the civil case said, "Jordan's parents and I were to surprised to learn about the recusal of Judge Cooper. Judges often have schedule and personal conflicts which cause them to step-down. Judge Healey is a learned trial judge. We respect and support him and hope he will keep the pace of this case as set by the Judges before him and have a jury decide this matter, as scheduled, in September/October."

Dunn's next pretrial hearing is scheduled for July 8.

Comments

The views expressed are not those of clickorlando.com, WKMG or its affiliated companies. This is a community moderated forum (Please note the 'Flag' button). By posting your comments you agree to accept our Terms Of service
blog comments powered by Disqus